Jammy Vanilla Buttercream Layer Cake
- Janine Ogden
- 2 days ago
- 4 min read

This is a great beginner recipe, using the 'egg weigh method' of creating the perfect sponge.
If your eggs weigh 370g, or 430g, just measure out the other main ingredients to that weight as well.
For perfect results, have EVERY ingredient at room temperature, and mix as lightly as possible once the flour is in there.
This buttercream recipe is what's referred to in baking circles as ABC - American buttercream, but it's the classic buttercream we all grew up with in the UK.
Jammy Vanilla Buttercream Layer Cake
Makes an 8" round cake, that's about 4" deep when filled and iced. Will serve up to 24 slices.
Prep approx 1 hour, plus cooling time.
Bake time 1 hour - 1hour 15 mins.
Ingredients
Remember when baking a sponge, every ingredient should be room temperature for best baking results.
For the sponge:
400g butter
400g sugar
400g eggs, weighed in shells
400g self raising flour
1 tbsp vanilla paste, or 2 tbsp vanilla extract
Splash of milk
For the buttercream:
300g butter, very soft - heat it gently until it's just starting to go liquid. Please note - you can use baking block if you are happy with the flavour & texture, but nothing from a tub, or it'll melt at a much lower temperature.
600g icing sugar, sifted to remove lumps
1 tsp vanilla paste, or 2 tbsp vanilla extract
For the filling & topping:
Any jam, preserve, curd etc that you prefer or have in the cupboard. You'll likely need a full jar, especially if you're a bit of a greedy fucker like me.
Directions:
Make sure your oven rack is in the centre of the oven, and preheat to 130C/260F if you have a fan oven, 150C/300F if it's not a fan oven, or gas mark 2. This is a deep cake so we need to bake low & slow, to make sure the middle is baked before the edges dry out.
Grease and bottom line an 8" cake tin (3" high one).
In a large bowl, cream your softened butter or baking spread with the sugar until smooth.
Add the vanilla paste or extract, and the eggs one at a time, whisking on a high speed. If the mixture looks like it is separating, add a spoonful of your flour. Keep going until smooth.
Sieve the flour, and mix in very gently, just until you can't see the flour any more and no further. If the mixture starts to feels stiff, add a splash of milk to loosen it. Take care not to over-mix or your cake will be dense.
Split equally between the tins and smooth the tops.
Bake for approx. 1 hour until it looks golden. Ovens can vary, so keep an eye on them - don't open the oven door until it's colouring well on top, or it'll sink in the middle. Put your ear close to the cake (please be careful, don't burn thi lughole!) - if you can hear it 'singing' they're not fully baked yet.
Cool in the tin on a wire rack. To remove from the tin, run a small palette knife around the edge of the cake to loosen, then tip the tin upside down and gently shake.
Meanwhile, make your buttercream:
Stir the vanilla paste into the very soft butter.
Sift the icing sugar to remove lumps, and mix into the butter. You can use a wooden spoon, silicon spatula, electric whisk, or the beater attachment of a stand mixer. Just be aware that if you use a whisk you may get air bubbles in your buttercream, but that's really not a big deal.
Leave your buttercream to stand for 5-10 mins so the sugar particles can dissolve into the butter. Using this method saves having to mix for a long time. Add a small splash of boiling water straight from the kettle, mix it in, and using a silicon spatula, paddle back & forth against the side of the bowl to smooth the buttercream.
To assemble:
Cut the sponge in half, and layer with your choice of jam and buttercream. Be aware that the jams and curds can be slippery, so you may wish to secure with a cake dowel through the middle of the cake.
Using a large palette knife, spread a very thin layer of buttercream over the whole cake - this is called a 'crumb coat' and will stop crumbs getting into the top layer of icing. Chill for 15 minutes.
Give the buttercream a good stir so it spreads easily - if it's too stiff then microwave for 10 seconds to loosen it.
Spread the buttercream over the whole cake. Do the top first, aiming for it to be level. Then spread around the sides, working the knife from side to side to create a rustic ruffle effect around the edge. If you have a straight edged scraper, run it around the cake to smooth the sides - but remember we're going rustic here, so no pressure to get it perfectly smooth.
Before the buttercream crusts, slightly warm the jam in the microwave so it goes a bit runny, then spoon it over the top, swirling into the top for a pretty marbled texture.
This cake can be made 2 days ahead - just keep refrigerated, then bring to room temperature before serving. If you eat it straight from the fridge, the fat content will be solid so your sponge will seem dry and your buttercream will be hard.
Can also be frozen - freeze it unwrapped, then loosely wrap in a few layers of cling film and then a cake box to protect it.
Defrost in the fridge overnight, still in it's packaging, before then bringing up to room temperature, to reduce the risk of condensation.
Comments